[env-trinity] Dinner gives update on Klamath, Eel dam removal, Groups ask locals to attend hearing on Feb. 6

Regina Chichizola klamathtrinityriver at gmail.com
Wed Feb 6 09:16:14 PST 2019

Dinner gives update on Klamath, Eel dam removalGroups ask locals to attend
hearing on Feb. 6



A fundraiser dinner at the Arcata Veterans Hall hosted by Save California
Salmon and Friends of the Eel River provided updates Saturday on the status
of the removal of several Klamath River dams, as well an insight into the
future of dam removal on the Eel River.

Regina Chichizola, who works with Save California Salmon, said the process
of removing the Klamath dams has been complicated, and the dinner was
intended to clarify any uncertainties that might exist.

“PacifiCorp was re-licensing the dams through the FERC (Federal Energy
Regulatory Commission) process,” she said. “Now that the dams are being
transferred to a dam removal entity, they have to redo the process for the
(water quality) certification and for the FERC EIS (environmental impact
statement) … this is the public process for the state of California to
remove the dams.”

Because of the change up from re-licensing for continued operation to
licensing with the intent to decommission the dams, hearings that have
already occurred for the initial re-licensing process have to happen again
for the purpose of dam decommissioning, she said.

Chichizola said a hearing for public comment on a draft version on an
environmental impact report, which is the next step in dam removal that
will factor into the state’s decision to grant a water quality
certification for the decommissioning project, will be taking place on
Wednesday, Feb. 6, at the D Street Community Center in Arcata from 5 to 8
p.m. Chichizola encourages people to come and offer their support for
Klamath dam removal.

“I think it’s going great. I’ve been working on dam removal now for 15
years,” she said. “All the evidence shows taking the dams down means that
we will have clean water and that salmon will be able to rebound in the
Klamath River … if we take the Eel River dams down too we might be able to
bring back the fishing industry.”

According to a document circulated at the event, “the Water Board staff
finds that, ‘In looking at the range of benefits and impacts the State
Water Board has identified the Proposed Project as the environmentally
superior alternative.'”

“The removal of the four dams … is definitely their preferred alternative,”
she said.

After the comment period on the draft Environmental Impact Report, the
state may issue a “final permit to remove the dams,” which will leave
the Klamath River Renewal Corporation waiting on the completion of another
process on the federal level for other permits required for dam removal,
Chichizola said.

Frankie Myers, vice-chairman of the Yurok Tribe, spoke briefly at the
event, but his words were met with a room full of applause.

“Dam removal on the Klamath is nearing the end,” he said. “On the Eel we
are making progress; the same efforts need to be shown to both at this time
… we are very close.”

Stephanie Tidwell, the executive director of Friends of the Eel River, said
the movement around the dams on the Eel River has been an interesting

“Things have changed so rapidly for the dams’ re-licensing process,” she
said. “I’m actually hopeful … . PG&E’s announcement that they’re going to
withdraw their application to re-license the dam basically means they have
to take Scott Dam out — I don’t see any way around it.”

The announcement, she said, has left the dam in an “abandoned state,” and
with the Pacific Gas and Electric Co. failing to find another party to
purchase and run the dam, removal is likely.

“They’ve been losing money on the power generation process for many many
years,” she said. “When those dams were built we didn’t have the Endangered
Species Act, we didn’t have the clean water act … . Basically it requires
fish passage; Scott Dam has no fish passage.”

Tidwell likened Scott Dam to “a wall of death,” and said the initial cost
analysis for installing fish ladders would number into the tens of millions.

“What was already a money-losing project becomes untenable from a corporate
perspective,” she said. “And so we and a lot of other groups have been
involved … to try and hammer out a solution.”

What we’re looking at now, Tidwell said, is a very different situation from
what things looked like eight days ago. The withdrawal of an application
for re-licensing by PG&E was akin to the company giving up on finding a
purchaser, she said, and, reading between the lines, it appears the dams
are likely to come down.

“We’ll know more as this process goes along,” she said. “Basically there is
now a 90-day window in which someone else could apply to buy the dam, but
if they couldn’t do it with PG&E offering them a lot of carrot and money
and studies, we can’t just possibly imagine how someone else could take it
on and continue with the federal re-licensing process which is what they’d
be required to do.”

For more information on the Feb. 6 hearing, visit the event page on
Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/events/319789575304930/.

*Philip Santos can be reached at 707-441-0506.*

Sign up for email newsletters
SUBSCRIBE <https://www.times-standard.com/newsletter/>
Follow Us

   - <https://facebook.com/TimesStandard>
   - <https://twitter.com/eurekaTS>
   - <https://instagram.com/etseurekatimesstandard>
   - <https://www.times-standard.com/feed/>


   1. Former Raiders QB dies; handed Bill Walsh ‘the most traumatic’ loss
   of his career
   2. Plan for Eureka to reconsider marketing services draws large crowd
   3. Crab season sees ‘sharp dropoff,’ fishermen say
   4. UPDATE: Crews continue to cleanup oil spill on Highway 101, which
   remains closed in both directions
   5. Mad River Community Hospital lays off handful of employees
   6. Man accused of child sex abuse takes 20-year plea deal

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www2.dcn.org/pipermail/env-trinity/attachments/20190206/9be3389b/attachment.html>

More information about the env-trinity mailing list